Nail Down vs Glue Down Wide Plank Flooring
Nail down and glue down are the two installation methods in our install guide, and in most homes the subfloor makes the choice. Over a plywood subfloor, wide plank flooring is nailed down over a felt moisture barrier. Over a concrete slab, the boards are glued directly to the concrete with a glue-down system.
Hardwood Design Company makes the flooring, and your builder or installer lays it. This guide is for homeowners, architects and designers planning a large custom build or a whole-home renovation, so you can talk through the method with the person installing your floor and make sure the plans give the boards what they need.
How Does the Subfloor Decide the Method?
Every wood floor starts with what sits underneath it. Flooring nails need wood to grip, so a nail-down installation calls for a plywood subfloor. A concrete slab gives a nail nothing to hold, which is why concrete calls for glue.
Plenty of custom homes have both. A house built on a slab with a framed second story may need a glued floor on the ground level and a nailed floor upstairs. When that is the plan, it helps to settle early whether one species, platform and finish will serve every level, so the whole house comes from a single order and reads as one floor.
Plywood Subfloors
Plywood over floor framing is the classic base for a nail-down floor. It should be flat, clean, dry and firmly fastened before the flooring arrives on site. Loose panels and squeaks are far easier to fix at this stage than after the boards are down.
Concrete Slabs
Concrete holds moisture long after the surface looks dry, and a slab poured during construction needs time to give it up. Your installer will test the slab and check that it is flat before any adhesive is spread. Our install guide calls for a dry subfloor before installation begins, so it is worth sharing with your builder well before the floor is on the schedule.
How Nail-Down Installation Works
Nail-down is the long-standing way to lay a solid wood floor, and it is the method many installers know best. Each board is fastened to the plywood below, so the floor and the subfloor work as one structure. It suits the framed floors found on the upper levels of most custom homes, and on the main level of homes built over a crawl space or basement.
The Felt Moisture Barrier
Before the first board goes down, the installer rolls out a felt moisture barrier over the plywood. It sits between the subfloor and the flooring and slows the movement of moisture from below. It also gives the boards a clean, even bed to sit on.
Nailing the Boards
Our guide calls for a pneumatic nailer and nails 1 1/2 to 2 inches long. The nails are driven at an angle through the tongue of each board, so the next board covers them and no fasteners show on the face. A careful installer sets the nailer's pressure so the tongue is held firmly without being crushed.
Leaving Room for the Wood to Move
Wood takes on and gives off moisture through the seasons, and it swells and shrinks a little as it does. A nail-down floor needs 1/2 inch of expansion space around the perimeter, which the baseboard later covers. On wide plank flooring this space matters even more, because each board has more width to move.
How Glue-Down Installation Works
On concrete, the boards are glued directly to the slab with a glue-down system. The adhesive holds the full underside of every board, which gives the floor a solid, planted feel underfoot.
Preparing the Slab
Adhesive only bonds as well as the surface it meets. The slab needs to be dry, flat and clean, with loose concrete, paint, drywall mud and other residue removed. High spots are ground down and low spots filled before the first trowel of adhesive goes on.
Choosing the Adhesive System
Your installer chooses the adhesive and any moisture control layer as one system and follows its maker's instructions to the letter. Spread rate, open time and trowel size all come from that system. Ask your installer which system they plan to use and how they will handle perimeter spacing on a glued floor, since those details follow NWFA guidance and the adhesive's own requirements.
Solid or Engineered: Which Suits Each Method?
Both solid and engineered boards suit a nail-down installation over plywood. Over concrete, many installers prefer engineered flooring for glue-down, because its layered construction is more dimensionally stable when moisture levels change. Engineered flooring still responds to moisture, so site conditions matter just as much.
We make Northern White Oak, French Oak and Southern Pecan in both solid and engineered. Our engineered Northern White Oak and Southern Pecan carry a sawn wear layer of 4.5 to 8 mm, so the top of every board is real sawn wood with the same grain and character as a solid plank. For a full side-by-side of the two platforms, read our guide to engineered vs solid wood floors.
Whichever platform your project needs, the boards are made the same way. At our facility in Bryan, Texas, we saw our own lumber, including the sawn wear layer for our engineered boards, cure and dry the wood, and mill the profile before every board is sanded and finished by hand, then ship each floor to homes across the United States. It is the same process behind every handcrafted hardwood floor we have made since 1998.
Site Conditions Come First
Neither method can make up for a wet or unsettled building. Our hardwood flooring install guide asks for the building to be closed in, the subfloor dry, and the space held at 60 to 80°F and 40 to 60% humidity for 14 days before, during and after installation. These conditions protect a nailed floor and a glued floor equally.
The guide also lists places where we do not recommend our flooring at all: full baths, hot tub enclosures and wine cellars. The constant humidity in those rooms works against any wood floor, however well it is made. For more on letting the boards settle into the house before they go down, see our post on acclimating wide plank hardwood flooring.
Planning the Conversation With Your Installer
You do not need to choose a trowel or set a nailer, but a few questions early in the project save a lot of trouble later. Ask what each level of the house is built on, and whether the floor will be nailed, glued or both. Ask how the installer will confirm the subfloor is dry and flat, and when they want the flooring delivered.
Architects can help a great deal at the drawing stage. Noting the subfloor type, the floor build-up and the finished floor height on the plans lets the stair maker, door hanger and trim carpenter work to the same numbers. Board thickness feeds straight into that build-up: Northern White Oak comes in 1, 13/16 and 3/4 inch thicknesses, French Oak in 1 and 7/8 inch, and Southern Pecan in 3/4 inch solid or 5/8 inch engineered. On a home with wide plank flooring, stair treads and wood ceilings in the same species, that shared set of drawings keeps every piece of wood in step.
Finally, make sure your installer has a copy of our install guide before the job starts. It follows NWFA guidelines, and handing it over early means everyone on site is working from the same instructions for a floor made specifically for your home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the installation method change how the floor looks?
No. Once the floor is down, a nailed floor and a glued floor look the same. The character you see comes from the species, the live sawn grain, the texture and the finish, so a Natural Face floor reads the same over plywood upstairs as it does over concrete downstairs.
Can unfinished boards be nailed or glued down?
Yes. We offer our flooring unfinished as well as finished, and unfinished boards can be installed with either method. Your flooring contractor then applies the finish on site once the floor is down, which is worth building into the project schedule so other trades are out of the room while it cures.
Who makes the final call between nail down and glue down?
Your installer and builder make the final call, based on the subfloor and the conditions on site. Your architect sets that up through the drawings, and we are happy to talk through species and platform options with all three so the boards ordered suit the method chosen.
Plan Your Floor Before the Subfloor Goes In
The best time to think about installation is while the house is still on paper. If you are planning a custom home or a whole-home renovation, get in touch with our team and we will help you choose the species, platform and finish that suit your subfloors, so your installer has everything needed to lay a floor you will love for decades.



